City Water 14 min read Updated Sep 29, 2026

The Worst Tap Water in America, by the Numbers

We ranked US states by EPA health-based water violations (2015-2024), raw and per person. See where tap water fails most and how to check your own address.

Last Updated
Published
By

FilterPicks Research Team

Water Filtration Analysts & Researchers
Data Verified

Key Takeaways

  • By raw count, Texas and Oklahoma log the most EPA health-based water violations; California is third.
  • Adjusted for population, the ranking flips: Alaska, Oklahoma, New Mexico, and Louisiana are worst per resident.
  • The worst per-capita states share one trait, many small rural systems that struggle to keep treatment running.
  • Most violations in the data are paperwork, not contamination. We counted only health-based violations.
  • A clean utility record does not rule out lead, which comes from home plumbing. Check your address and consider a test.

Ask where the worst tap water in America is and you get the same short list of cities, usually with no numbers attached. We wanted an answer you could check, so we went to the federal government’s enforcement records: every Safe Drinking Water Act violation on file, more than 1.1 million of them. We ranked the states two ways, by how often their systems break a health standard and by how often they do it per resident. Then we split the same records by contaminant, because arsenic, nitrate, disinfection byproducts and “forever chemicals” need different filters and turn up in different places. That split is also where the individual cities show up.

Check your own address, not just the state. The rankings below are state and city averages. Our free checker reads the same EPA data for your exact water system, shows which contaminants are on record, and names the certified filter that removes each one.

How we counted, and why it matters

The records come from the EPA’s Safe Drinking Water Information System, or SDWIS, where every public water system reports its violations. Two choices decide whether a ranking built on it means anything. The first is what to count. Most SDWIS violations are monitoring and reporting failures: a utility filed paperwork late or skipped a required test. We dropped all of those and kept only health-based violations, the cases where a system exceeded a federal health limit for an actual contaminant. That is the number tied to water quality, and it is a small share of the total. Oklahoma logged around 9,000 monitoring violations in 2024 against roughly 1,300 health-based ones. The second is the time frame. Reporting was patchy before the mid-2010s, so older years look clean mainly because fewer systems filed anything. We used 2015 through 2024, where coverage holds steady. Every map and every system named below comes from that same set: health-based violations, community water systems, 2015 to 2024.

The raw ranking: Texas and Oklahoma lead

Bar chart of total EPA health-based drinking water violations by state, 2015 to 2024, with Texas and Oklahoma highest
Health-based violations only. Monitoring and reporting violations are excluded.

Texas has the most health-based violations of any state, close to 14,000 over the decade. Part of that is size: Texas runs about 7,000 water systems, more than anywhere else. Oklahoma is the surprise. It serves roughly a tenth of California’s population and still recorded more than 10,000 health-based violations, almost matching California outright. The top of the list is regional. Texas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, New Mexico, Kansas and Arkansas form a Southern and Plains block where the failures concentrate in small rural systems. Most of the trouble comes from disinfection byproducts, which form when chlorine reacts with organic matter and are the most common health-based violation nationwide, plus naturally occurring nitrate and arsenic in farm and groundwater country.

Adjust for population and the map flips

Bar chart of water violations per 100,000 residents, with Alaska and Oklahoma highest
Health-based violations per 100,000 residents. Texas 47.8, California 18.8, New York 12.3 for comparison.

Raw counts favor big states. Divide by population and the order almost reverses. Per 100,000 residents, Alaska comes out worst at about 292, then Oklahoma at 265, New Mexico at 167 and Louisiana at 132. California drops from third to about 19 per 100,000. New York sits near 12. The states that move up are small, rural and mountainous: West Virginia, Wyoming, Kansas, South Dakota, Idaho, Arkansas, Montana. The cause is the one behind the raw numbers too. These states are served by large numbers of very small systems, some with only a few hundred customers, that cannot afford to run and maintain complex treatment. One small system that keeps missing the disinfection-byproduct limit counts for far more in a state of 600,000 people than in a state of 30 million.

What’s actually in the water

A state total shows how often systems fail. It does not show what they fail for, and the fix depends entirely on that. So we split the same health-based records by chemical. Four contaminants account for most of the violations, and each has its own geography, mapped below. Two more, PFAS and lead, rank among the most-searched water worries in the country and cannot be ranked from enforcement data at all. We cover all six, with the certified filter that handles each.

Disinfection byproducts: the most common failure

US tile-grid map of health-based disinfection byproduct violations by state, 2015 to 2024, with Oklahoma, Texas and Louisiana highest
Health-based TTHM and HAA5 violations, community water systems, 2015–2024. Source: FilterPicks analysis of EPA SDWIS.

Utilities have to add chlorine or chloramine to kill microbes. When those disinfectants meet natural organic matter in the water, they form byproducts, mainly total trihalomethanes (TTHM) and five haloacetic acids (HAA5). Long-term exposure is associated with a higher risk of bladder cancer, so the EPA caps TTHM at 80 parts per billion and HAA5 at 60. At more than 30,000 violations over the decade, this is the most common health-based failure in the country. It sits almost entirely in small Southern systems. Oklahoma leads by a wide margin at nearly 7,800 violations, ahead of Texas (about 5,100) and Louisiana (about 3,700). Warm surface water carries a heavy organic load, and small utilities often lack the treatment budget to keep byproducts down. Dozens of small Oklahoma systems, among them Boswell, Waurika and Maysville, logged around 60 violations each, several with TTHM above 250 ppb, more than three times the limit. Larger cities show up too. Jackson, Mississippi recorded results as high as 115 ppb, and both Shreveport, Louisiana and Laredo, Texas had repeat exceedances. The fix: activated carbon. A good carbon pitcher or faucet filter cuts TTHM and HAA5 at the tap, and a whole-house carbon tank handles it at the main. See the Brita and Waterdrop reviews, or run your address through the water quality checker.

Arsenic: the Southwest and the Central Valley

US tile-grid map of health-based arsenic violations by state, 2015 to 2024, with California and Texas highest
Health-based arsenic violations, community water systems, 2015–2024. Source: FilterPicks analysis of EPA SDWIS.

Arsenic occurs naturally in groundwater across much of the West, and long exposure raises the risk of skin, bladder and lung cancer along with cardiovascular and developmental harm. The federal limit is 10 parts per billion. California (about 2,300 violations) and Texas (about 2,200) lead, followed by Arizona, New Mexico and Nevada, with a smaller pocket in New England groundwater. A few systems stand out. Camino Real Regional Utility Authority in Sunland Park, New Mexico logged 43 health-based arsenic violations through 2024, with results up to 28 ppb. Arvin, in California’s Central Valley, recorded arsenic as high as 45 ppb, more than four times the limit. Tri County Special Utility District near Marlin, Texas passed 100 violations over the decade, the longest arsenic record in our data. These are small and mid-sized systems, and the arsenic sits in the source water, not the pipes. The fix: reverse osmosis. An under-sink or countertop RO system certified to NSF/ANSI 58 removes arsenic; carbon pitchers do not. Compare AquaTru, APEC and Waterdrop.

Nitrate: farm country’s contaminant

US tile-grid map of health-based nitrate violations by state, 2015 to 2024, with California and Texas highest
Health-based nitrate violations, community water systems, 2015–2024. Source: FilterPicks analysis of EPA SDWIS.

Nitrate leaches into shallow groundwater from fertilizer, manure and septic systems, so its map follows agriculture. California (about 1,300 violations) and Texas (about 1,100) lead, then Kansas, Arizona and Washington. The limit is 10 milligrams per liter. Nitrate carries an acute risk on top of the long-term one: above the limit it can cause potentially fatal “blue baby syndrome” in infants under six months. Boiling does not fix it and makes it worse, since boiling concentrates the nitrate. The Central Valley is the center of it. Farm towns such as McFarland recorded nitrate around 14 mg/L, and some very small Central Valley systems reported more than 130 mg/L, over thirteen times the limit. Burkburnett, Texas came in near 29 mg/L. The fix: reverse osmosis or a nitrate-selective anion-exchange system. Carbon does not remove it, and do not boil. The AquaTru and APEC RO systems are certified for nitrate.

Radium and uranium: the radioactive belt

US tile-grid map of health-based radionuclide violations by state, 2015 to 2024, with Texas, Colorado and Wisconsin highest
Health-based radium, uranium and gross-alpha violations, community water systems, 2015–2024. Source: FilterPicks analysis of EPA SDWIS.

Some aquifers hold naturally radioactive elements, chiefly radium and uranium, and long exposure raises the risk of bone cancer and kidney damage. The limits are low: 5 picocuries per liter for combined radium, 15 for gross alpha, 30 ppb for uranium. Texas (about 2,600 violations) and Colorado (about 1,300) lead, with a separate cluster in Wisconsin and the upper Midwest. Two systems stand out. Waukesha, Wisconsin fought radium for years, with more than 100 violations in this window, and eventually won federal approval to pipe in Lake Michigan water rather than treat its own. Brady, Texas carries some of the highest radium in the country: more than 200 health-based violations over the decade, with results near 48 pCi/L, close to ten times the limit. Colorado’s Arkansas River Valley, around La Junta and Manzanola, forms a smaller version of the same problem. The fix: reverse osmosis removes radium, uranium and gross-alpha emitters, and a cation-exchange water softener captures radium. NSF/ANSI 58 RO systems such as AquaTru and Waterdrop are the point-of-use option.

PFAS: why the rankings can’t show it

PFAS, the “forever chemicals” in firefighting foam, industrial discharge and consumer goods, are probably the most-searched water contaminant in the country and the hardest to rank from enforcement data. A 2023 U.S. Geological Survey study estimated that at least 45% of US tap water contains one or more PFAS, with detection far more likely in cities (around 75%) than in rural areas (about 25%). There is still no honest “worst cities for PFAS” violation table, for two reasons. The EPA only set the first federal PFAS limits in April 2024, at 4 parts per trillion for PFOA and PFOS and 10 ppt for three others, and the nationwide monitoring behind them is not finished. Almost every PFAS record in the enforcement data so far is a monitoring entry, not an exceedance. In May 2026 the EPA proposed pushing the compliance deadline to 2031 and rescinding several of the newer limits, so the rules themselves are still moving. The occurrence data does point to where PFAS concentrates: downstream of manufacturing, such as the Cape Fear River and Wilmington, North Carolina; parts of New Jersey, which has measured some of the highest levels in the country; the mid-Ohio Valley near Parkersburg, West Virginia; and communities around military bases and airports that used firefighting foam. Near any of those, treat PFAS as likely until a test says otherwise. The fix: reverse osmosis, or a filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53 for PFOA and PFOS (the Brita Elite and ZeroWater pitchers both hold it), or the broader NSF/ANSI 473 certification. Our water quality checker will add PFAS detection data as the EPA finalizes its monitoring results.

Lead: why it’s not on any of these maps

Lead is the reason many people search for a page like this, and it is the one contaminant the maps above cannot show. It rarely comes from the treatment plant or the source water. It leaches from a home’s own lead service line and interior plumbing, which is why it is governed by an “action level” that triggers a utility response rather than a health-based limit, and why it often never reaches a system’s violation record. A clean compliance history is not the same as a clean lead test. The scale is national. The EPA’s 2023 inventory counted an estimated 9 million lead service lines still in use. Chicago has more than any other city, roughly 400,000, because it required lead service lines by ordinance until the federal ban in 1986. The known crises trace back to the same source: Flint, Michigan (a 2014 source switch and a corrosion-control failure), Newark, New Jersey (which replaced lead service lines across the city), and more recently Benton Harbor, Michigan. The 2024 Lead and Copper Rule Improvements cut the action level from 15 to 10 parts per billion and require most lead lines replaced within a decade, though that work is years off for most cities. The fix: a filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53 for lead, either a certified pitcher such as the Brita Elite for renters or an under-sink or countertop RO system such as AquaTru for owners. Because public data will not flag lead, a certified test at your own tap is the only way to be sure. Our guide to lead filters covers the certified options.

Is it getting worse?

Health-based violations have risen across the worst states over the past 15 years. In Texas they went from about 260 a year in 2008 to more than 2,200 in 2024, and in Louisiana from roughly 65 to 750. Most of that reflects more testing rather than worse water. Oklahoma’s monitoring violations jumped from about 500 a year to roughly 9,000 over the same span, which means far more systems are being tracked and tested than a decade ago. As the pool of reporting systems grew, the raw counts climbed with it. What holds up is a persistent, structural weakness in small-system treatment, not a sudden collapse in water quality.

What a violation does and does not mean

A violation is a regulatory event fixed to a point in time. It means a system exceeded a limit; it does not prove the water in a given house is dangerous, and many are resolved quickly. Two things matter more than the count.

  • A clean record is not a guarantee. Lead is the clearest case. It usually comes from a home’s own pipes, so it never shows up in the utility’s history. No violations on file does not mean no lead at your tap.
  • Monitoring failures are not contamination. When a site calls a town’s water toxic over “hundreds of violations,” check whether those are paperwork. Ours are not.

This ranking shows where systems most often miss federal standards. It cannot tell you what comes out of your faucet today. Only a test can do that.

How to check your own water

A statewide figure, or even a citywide one, says nothing about a single address. Start with our free water quality checker, which looks your utility up in this same EPA data and shows the health-based violations on record for your system, keeps monitoring issues separate, and flags the contaminants that matter. Then read your utility’s Consumer Confidence Report, the annual summary every community system publishes, which lists what was detected. Neither replaces a certified test at your tap, which is the only way to catch lead.

See what’s on record for your water system. Enter a ZIP code or city to see your utility’s health-based violations, the contaminants behind them, and the filter that fixes each. It takes about ten seconds and it’s free.

What to do about it

A filter only works if it is certified for the contaminant you have. Match the fix to the problem.

  • Lead: a filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53. A certified pitcher such as the Brita Elite for renters; owners can add an under-sink or countertop reverse osmosis system like AquaTru, APEC or Waterdrop. See our guide to lead filters.
  • Disinfection byproducts the main problem in the states above: activated carbon, whether a pitcher, a faucet filter or a whole-house tank.
  • Arsenic, nitrate, radium or uranium: reverse osmosis (NSF/ANSI 58), or a contaminant-specific media. Do not boil nitrate.
  • PFAS: reverse osmosis, or a pitcher certified to NSF/ANSI 53 for PFOA and PFOS.
  • On a private well: public data does not cover you. Test first, then filter to the result.

References

Health-based violation counts are FilterPicks’ own tabulation of SDWIS records for community water systems, 2015–2024. This article uses public EPA data, which reflects self-reported and modeled records and is not a substitute for testing your own water. Some links are affiliate links; they do not change our recommendations or your price.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which state has the worst tap water?

It depends on how you count. By raw number of health-based violations from 2015 to 2024, Texas has the most, close to 14,000. Adjusted for population the order changes: Alaska and Oklahoma are worst per resident. Oklahoma stands out either way, with more than 10,000 violations despite serving about a tenth of California's population.

What are the worst cities for PFAS?

There is no reliable violation-based ranking yet. Federal PFAS limits were only set in 2024 and the nationwide monitoring behind them is not finished, so most PFAS records so far are paperwork, not exceedances. The best-documented hotspots are Wilmington, North Carolina on the Cape Fear River, parts of New Jersey, and the area around Parkersburg, West Virginia, plus communities near military bases that used firefighting foam. A 2023 USGS study estimated at least 45% of US tap water contains some PFAS.

Which cities have the worst lead problems?

Lead usually comes from a home's own service line rather than the utility, so it does not map like other contaminants. Chicago has the most lead service lines of any US city, roughly 400,000. Flint, Michigan and Newark, New Jersey are the best-known recent crises. Because lead is a plumbing problem, a certified test at your own tap is the only way to know your risk.

Does a water violation mean my water is dangerous?

Not on its own. A health-based violation means a system exceeded a federal limit at some point, and many are fixed quickly. Treat it as a reason to check your specific address, not as proof your tap is unsafe today.

My city has no violations. Is my water safe?

Not necessarily. Lead comes from household plumbing and rarely appears in a utility's record, so a clean compliance history is not the same as a clean test at your faucet.

What filter removes each contaminant?

Activated carbon (pitcher, faucet or whole-house) handles disinfection byproducts. Reverse osmosis certified to NSF/ANSI 58 handles arsenic, nitrate, radium and uranium. A filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53 handles lead and, for PFOA and PFOS, PFAS. Match the certification to the contaminant you actually have.

How do I find out what is in my water?

Start with our free water quality checker, which reads the EPA record for your system, then read your utility's annual Consumer Confidence Report. For lead specifically, use a certified test at your own tap.

By

FilterPicks Research Team

Water Filtration Analysts & Researchers

The FilterPicks Research Team is a group of water quality analysts, researchers, and writers dedicated to providing accurate, unbiased reviews and educational content. Our team combines expertise in water filtration technology, contaminant analysis, and product testing to help homeowners make informed decisions about their drinking water.

Expertise: Water Filtration Analysis Water Quality Testing Filtration Technology Company Reviews
Data Verified
Disclaimer: This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Consult with a qualified water treatment professional for specific concerns about your water supply. Water quality and filtration results may vary based on local conditions.